Engine Guides · 13 engines

Engine Problems Guide: Which Engines to Buy and Avoid

With a used car, the engine code often matters more than the badge. The same model can be a safe buy with one engine and an expensive mistake with another, and the same engine can be fine after one year and risky before it.

Each engine below has its main fault, the cars it is found in and a one-line verdict. The full guide behind each one covers the years affected, what a repair costs and the checks you can do yourself at the viewing.

Sound engineno design flawDepends on the yearsafe after a certain year or generationBuy with careonly with the paperwork or the budget

Volkswagen Group (VW, Audi, Skoda, SEAT)

2.0 TDI

Depends on the year
Diesel · PD, EA189, EA288
Found in
Golf, Passat, Tiguan, Octavia, Superb, Leon, Audi A3 and A4, since 2003
Main fault
Three generations with different weak points: the oil pump drive on some PD engines, EGR and particulate filter on the EA189, the water pump on the EA288.
Verdict
EA288 (2012 on) is the one to have. A late EA189 with history is fine. Avoid PD engines with the balance shaft unit unless the fix is on an invoice.
Read the 2.0 TDI guide →

EA888 2.0 TFSI

Depends on the year
Petrol turbo
Found in
The 2.0 petrol turbo across the VW Group range, from about 2008
Main fault
Oil burning and a plastic timing-chain tensioner on Gen 1 and Gen 2 engines (about 2008–2012). The tensioner can end the engine.
Verdict
Gen 3 (2012 on) is the one to buy. Earlier engines only with proof the faults were fixed.
Read the EA888 2.0 TFSI guide →

EA113 2.0 TFSI

Buy with care
Petrol turbo
Found in
Golf GTI Mk5, Audi A3 (8P) and TT, before the EA888 replaced it
Main fault
The cam follower wears through and destroys the high-pressure fuel pump.
Verdict
A good car if the follower is checked regularly. Walk away if the seller has never heard of it.
Read the EA113 2.0 TFSI guide →

Audi 3.0, 4.2 and V12 TDI

Depends on the year
Diesel · V6, V8, V12
Found in
Audi Q7 from 2006
Main fault
Timing chains at the back of the engine: four on the early 3.0 TDI (2006–2010). Swirl flaps and particulate filters on cars used in town.
Verdict
The 3.0 TDI from 2010 is the one to buy. Earlier 3.0 only with chain work done or priced in.
Read the Audi 3.0, 4.2 and V12 TDI guide →

BMW

N47

Depends on the year
Diesel · 2.0 four-cylinder
Found in
BMW four-cylinder diesels such as the 116d, 118d, 120d, 320d and 520d
Main fault
The timing chain sits at the back of the engine, behind the gearbox, and can wear and fail.
Verdict
Yes, with conditions: a later build (2011 on) where possible, regular oil changes on record, and silence from the rear of the engine on a cold start.
Read the N47 guide →

B58

Sound engine
Petrol turbo · 3.0 six
Found in
M240i, M340i, 540i, X3 M40i, Z4 M40i and Toyota Supra
Main fault
No single design flaw. Known items by mileage, covered in the guide; condition and tuning history matter most.
Verdict
BMW’s strongest six in 20 years, but not faultless. Buy on history, not on the model.
Read the B58 guide →

S58

Buy with care
Petrol twin-turbo · 3.0 six
Found in
M2 (G87), M3 (G80), M4 (G82), X3 M and X4 M
Main fault
It fixed the S55’s rod-bearing weakness, but has failure modes of its own to check at a viewing.
Verdict
A sound M engine. Buy standard, with a full history.
Read the S58 guide →

N55 vs S55

Buy with care
Petrol turbo · 3.0 six
Found in
N55: 335i, 435i, 535i, M235i, M135i. S55: M3 (F80), M4 (F82), M2 Competition
Main fault
The N55 is the everyday engine. The S55 is the M engine, with a rod-bearing reputation.
Verdict
N55 for a fast daily car that isn’t a project. S55 if you want the M car and budget for its upkeep.
Read the N55 vs S55 guide →

S55 rod bearings

Buy with care
Petrol twin-turbo · M3 F80
Found in
BMW M3 (F80) and M4 (F82)
Main fault
Rod bearings wear, and have destroyed engines past 100,000 km (60,000 miles).
Verdict
A known, fixed-cost item: oil analysis from 60,000 km, replace the bearings at 100,000–120,000 km. Past that without the work, have it done or walk away.
Read the S55 rod bearings guide →

Ford, Peugeot and Citroën

Ford 1.0 EcoBoost

Depends on the year
Petrol turbo · three-cylinder
Found in
Fiesta, Focus, B-Max, C-Max, EcoSport, Puma and small Ford vans, from 2012
Main fault
Until about 2018 the timing belt runs inside the engine oil. It can break down early and block the oil pump’s strainer.
Verdict
The chain engine (about 2018 on, every Puma, mild hybrids) is the safe buy. A wet-belt car only with an invoice for a full belt change.
Read the Ford 1.0 EcoBoost guide →

1.6 HDi / TDCi

Depends on the year
Diesel · four-cylinder
Found in
Peugeot, Citroën, Ford, Mazda, Volvo and Mini small diesels
Main fault
Turbo failure from oil starvation on the 16-valve engine (about 2004–2011). Replacing the turbo without fixing the cause kills the next one.
Verdict
The 8-valve engine (2011 on) is the one to buy. Earlier engines only with proof of the fixes.
Read the 1.6 HDi / TDCi guide →

Nissan, Jeep, Dodge and Ram

Nissan VQ37VHR

Depends on the year
Petrol · 3.7 V6
Found in
Nissan 370Z, Infiniti G37, M37, FX37 and QX70
Main fault
It uses oil, which worries owners more than it should. The water pump is a service item at around 100,000 km (60,000 miles).
Verdict
Not a fragile engine. A 2013-or-later car with oil services on record is the one to buy.
Read the Nissan VQ37VHR guide →

Hemi, Pentastar and EcoDiesel

Depends on the year
Petrol V6 and V8 · 3.0 diesel
Found in
Jeep Grand Cherokee, Dodge Charger, Challenger and Durango, Ram 1500
Main fault
Five engines with five different weak points, from the Pentastar’s oil cooler housing to the diesel’s need for regular long runs.
Verdict
Lowest risk: the 3.6 Pentastar from 2014. Best V8 to live with: the 5.7 Hemi with oil-change records.
Read the Hemi, Pentastar and EcoDiesel guide →

Looking at an engine that isn't here?

The free analyzer covers far more engines than we have written guides for. Enter the car, its year and mileage, and it lists the known faults for that engine, what they cost and what to check.